Perfect Sous Vide New York Strip Steak Recipe (2024)

FAQs

How long do you sous vide a New York strip steak? ›

​Sous vide cooking time for New York strip

The minimum cooking time for a New York strip steak is one hour. We recommend cooking your steak in the sous vide for 2 hours. Avoiding leaving a steak in the sous vide for longer than 4 hours.

The short answer is that it's very tough to predict exactly how spices are going to react in a sous-vide bag. I've found that if I want spice flavor, it's better to rub the spices into the meat after the sous-vide cooking phase and before the final searing phase.

Q: Can I add aromatics, like herbs or alliums, to the sous vide bag? Yes, you can. I like to add thyme or rosemary sprigs, along with sliced shallots or garlic cloves, to the bags with my steaks during cooking. Adding the same aromatics to the pan as you sear the steaks will bolster that flavor.

You should select a different cut of steak. A long trip in the sous vide bath is meant to break down connective tissue and tenderize meats. Flank steak is very lean, and inherently tough, so there is little connective tissue to break down, hence is stays tough.

After 3 to 4 hours, the texture of your steak will change. It will become more mushy. That is why it is recommended that you only cook until done (1 to 2 hours). So, overdoing it, as you describe it, would be cooking it too long so that the texture becomes undesirable.

I recommend seasoning meat before you cook it sous vide. Herbs and spices don't stick to cooked foods as well as raw, so nothing you make will be as seasoned as you like if you don't season prior to cooking.

Kenji Lopez-Alt said that he doesn't suggest adding fat (butter or olive oil) to the bag when cooking steak sous vide. He theorized that the added fat was absorbing fat-soluble flavor compounds from the meat and then being poured down the drain with the bag juice/butter.

In the kitchen, you have to produce flavor, and then lock in that flavor. This is why we sear the meat before cooking sous vide. During the cooking process, the flavors are enhanced and reach the core of the steak. Finally, the flavor is secured in the meat during the chilling process.

Here at Sous Vide Tools we often like to add a small amount of butter to the bag and find that for best results, flavoured butter works really well to add a little something extra during the cooking process. Our preference is to place butter into the bag itself, rather than on top of the product.

Can you overdo steak in sous vide? ›

For example, many chefs recommend that sous vide steak should not be cooked for longer than four hours because the connective tissue begins to break down and the steak can become mushy.

Preheat a sous vide cooker to desired final temperature. (See note below for temperature and timing charts, or find the same charts here.) Season steaks generously with salt and pepper. Place in sous vide bags along with herbs, garlic, and shallots (if using) and distribute evenly.

Your steak is chewy and tough most likely because the cut of steak was not tender to begin with. Another reason your steak is chewy and tough could be that you overcooked or undercooked the steak. Your steak could also be chewy and tough because you didn't let it rest long enough after cooking it.

Grill for 9–12 minutes for a 1-inch steak, and 12–14 minutes for a 1½ inch steak, turning about 1 minute before the halfway point. A meat thermometer should read 130°F. Rest your steaks for 5 minutes before serving, covering lightly with foil.

Sous Vide the Steak for 1-3 Hours

If you are cooking two small steaks one hour in the sous vide is sufficient. For more than two steaks or larger cuts, sous vide for at least two hours. For our massive King Cut steaks, cook with the immersion circulator for three hours.

For sirloin sous vide, set aside about one hour of time per inch of steak thickness. So, for a one-inch sirloin, you'll need about two hours, and a two-inch sirloin needs about three hours. Regardless of thickness and your preferred doneness level, you shouldn't need longer than four hours to sous vide sirloin steak.

My rule of thumb is TWO to FOUR hours for a TWO INCH STEAK, ONE to TWO hours TOPS for a ONE INCH STEAK and no longer. Sure, you can do it for MUCH longer (I've had steaks that has been sous-vided for more than EIGHT hours) but you're really not going to like the texture.